English essay
Imitation and reinforcement are the most crucial tools for
CLA
Towards the end
of the transcript, Tom uses an interrogative in the utterance ‘is (.) is dat
your talker’ by using Halliday’s representational function to request facts and
information. He uses this representational function by using over extension by
category with the concrete noun ‘talker’ due to Tom not knowing what the object
is himself. Due to Tom repeating the irregular verb ‘is’ suggests that he is
thinking about what to call the tape recorder, reinforcing Vygotsky’s CLA stage
as Tom is trying to independently think for himself. However, the use of the interrogative
implies Tom is hinting for help with what to call the tape recorder showing
intelligence due to him understanding that by putting the stative verb ‘is’ at
the beginning, initiates a question. This gives evidence for Tom being in the Zone
of Proximal Development as he understands he needs scaffolding to be able to
get the correct term. The phonetic spelling of the determiner ‘dat’ is an immature
pronunciation of ‘that’ suggesting Tom has not yet got the full idea of how to
pronounce the morpheme ‘th’. In contrast, later on in the transcript, Tom pronounces
‘three’ correctly. This could be because his Mother replies with ‘that’s’ modelling
the morpheme pronunciation or it could be a type error. As well as this, Tom
uses the determiner ’your’ to refer to his Mother but because she replies with
the interrogative ‘my talker?’ indicates that Tom did not make it clear he was addressing his mum. This could be
because he was either not close to his mother or that there was other people in
the room at this point in time.
The second part
of the Mothers utterance is a declarative with ‘that’s a tape recorder’. Although negative reinforcement is being
displayed with the mum using the standard form of ‘that’s’, it seems to be modelling which is
being taken place, with the subject being the proper noun ‘tape recorder’ and
the Mother focusing on correcting Toms accuracy rather than his grammar. This supports Brown and Hanson’s theory as
they say children rarely get corrected on their grammar but more on
truthfulness and politeness.
Before this part
in the transcript, Tom asks the interrogative ‘is these drawing Cartoon Network
cup of tea mum’. Tom uses the irregular verb
from ‘to be’ with the verb ‘is’ at the start of his utterance, which shows how
Tom uses this regularly to begin his questions.
The missing agreement inflection with the determiner ‘these’ and the verb
‘is’, as well as with the subject ‘ drawing’, with the missing morpheme ‘s’,
gives evidence of Tom being in the Telegraphic stage. This is because there is
enough information for the sentence to just make sense even with it being
grammatically wrong. Due to children at
this stage getting mixed up with objects and words, suggests that Tom may be overgeneralizing the proper noun ‘Cartoon Network’ with the picture on the cup. However, there
is evidence of Tom moving into the post-telegraphic stage with Tom’s utterance
containing 8 morphemes. The average number of morphemes for his age is 3.5 to 4
suggesting Tom is gaining more sophistication within his sentences. Tom ends
his interrogative with the vocative ‘mum’ showing he may be seeking reinforcement
as he is specifying who he wants reassurance from.
The determiner ‘these’ has deictic reference
as we do not know how close Tom is to the cup because young children are not
normally allowed close to hot drinks. The noun phrase ‘cup of tea’ shows how
Tom may know the liquid in the cup is hot even if he cannot see what is inside
as he has learnt through language that people call a mug full of tea a ‘cup of
tea’. The cup may not contain any tea so Tom may just associate mugs with the
drink tea. Even though
this is an
example of the symbolic stage which is normally found in 7 year olds plus, Tom
is beginning to take in information through different forms such as language
and because he has learnt this noun phrase, implies Tom has been around a cup
of tea before. As a result, this may be a local topic. ‘Cartoon network’ is
also a local topic for Tom due to it being a children’s channel, this implies
that Tom will have some knowledge as to whether the picture is actually from
this channel. This proper noun also
shows how Tom is in the iconic stage because he is remembering information
through images.
Because Tom is
not completely sure whether the picture is from Cartoon Network indicates Hallidays’
Heuristic function is being displayed, with Tom wanting to learn whether the
picture on the cup is what he thinks it to be through a question. Halliday’s representational
function is also present with Tom requesting information from his Mum, the
information being whether the image displayed on the cup is from Cartoon
Network.
All of this allows me to come to the conclusion that reinforcement is a crucial learning tool when it comes to a child understanding when they are right or wrong in terms of the language they use. Although many other learning tools are just as important such as the different stages in language and a child gaining different skills in how to learn language, if a child does not learn whether the language they have used is right or wrong, then they will not know whether they are using the correct grammatical terms.