Labels do not
determine your power
Why are all men addressed as ‘Mr’ married or not? [Pause for
3 seconds while making eye contact with many people]Is it because all men are
equal no matter what their relationship status? [Quick pause]If it is to do
with equality, then why are unmarried women addressed as ‘Miss’ and married
‘Mrs’? Is sexism still a big part of
humanity?
When you are sat in a classroom and you address the teacher
as Mr – when male- you do not know whether [say it while using hands as a way
of showing opposites] this male is neither married nor single. As a result,
this does not affect how you see this person and you [making eye contact while
pointing] do not see them beyond their personal power in the classroom. Do you
not? But this is not the case when it comes to females [pause to give thinking
time]. As soon as you here the teacher being addressed as Miss, you instantly
know that she is not married. In some cases, this could be a sign that she is
not [using the gesture for an apostrophe] ‘settled down’ –even though she may
have been in a stable relationship for many years. This could either make you see
this teacher not as powerful as she would be if married where she would be
addressed as ‘Mrs’ as it is an official sign that this women is wed.
But marriage does not mean between a man and a women… [Pause
for effect]
By stating this alone shows how the title of Miss or Mrs is
not determined by a males power. How men do not determine a women’s status in
her work place. Does a female not get a job purely on being a ‘Miss’ or Mrs’?
NO [say louder, more passionate but not shouting] I know stereotypes will
believe you to be married to the opposite sex but there is a stereotype for
everything! Why should you [eye contact] when you are older feel ashamed in
whom you marry?
If the concrete noun ‘Mr’ is used to address all men, then
surely there is a reason, is it because men dominate conversation when it comes
to communicating with the opposite sex? Zimmerman and West found that 95% of
men interrupted during a conversation with females. The use of the noun ‘Mr’
therefore could be seen as the reason for why men perceive themselves of having
a superior status. However, 5% [puts up 5 fingers] of these men did not interrupt
in conversation. This implies that not all men are dominant within conversation
and maybe it is to do with individual differences. Could men just be ruder?
When a doctor or a Professor, the person- no matter what sex- is addressed as Dr for Doctor or Pro for Professor. They have [counting on fingers] the same job, personal power and status and [moving both hands outwards in synchrony] still seen as equal. But why is this seen as a surprise? [Pause for 2 seconds] This question I just made may be more of a shock to women as it does to men, because it is suggesting how women finally are seen as equals in the workplace to males. It might just be in these lexical fields but somewhere, someone has made the mend! As a doctor or a professor is [counting on fingers] a high paid, educated well-earned job, this equality may be a bribe. As men might say [Says sarcastically] ‘Some females are actually as good as we are when it comes to work so they can finally be seen as equals’ This is very old-fashioned views and is why I am saying how this inequality of women being picked out as not being married is wrong!
[Starts walking round as it is a bit of topic so can engage
with people more with a laid back vibe]After the Second World War-[tilting head
forward] before your time- working class mothers had to stay at home and look
after the children. They were seen as stay at home wives and had this label of
stay at home mothers. Females had neither time nor money to go and get a degree
while the men went off to work .This divide with being married stay at home
mothers and non-married women who were seen to not have a stable lifestyle has
lived on until this day and age and it is now- I believe- outdated. We are not
involved in a war in this country like we were in world war two so why live
like it?
Berstein and Labov’s research oppose how women are classed
as equals only when or if they become a doctor or professor, due to their
results showing how a man’s perceived higher status is nothing to do with their
intelligence. This just sums up how this labelling is outrageous and should
never make you or any female feel less important or less manageable of having a
high skilled job than men.
Labels do not determine your power… so don’t let them!
My audience
is College students as I want to inform them on how having Labels do not
determine the power you have and will have after college because these pupils
will be going off and getting jobs and applying to university so need to know
that nothing will stop them getting what they want if they try.
A clear opinion and a good specific audience (state it beore you start).
ReplyDeleteCheck your Zimmerman and West facts.
How are you going to differentiate Dr and Doctor? I think the abbreviation for Professor is Prof.
You need more theory and you need to find a way to work it in where they understand why it is being used. You can't just use theorists' names as if they are supposed to know who they are and you need to paraphrase or gloss/explain linguistic terms like 'lexical field'.
Promising - needs more linguistic content that is transformed suitably for the audience.